Update:Honda Mobilio vs Maruti Ertiga Review
Honda’s seven seater Mobilio launches later this month set to take on the likes of Maruti Suzuki Ertiga, Chevrolet Enjoy and Nissan Evalia. Considering Ertiga is the leader in this segment, we have a comparison review of the two.
Design: Visual appeal of the Ertiga instantly stands out as a Maruti Suzuki product. Its façade resembles both Swift and Ritz hatchbacks with similar looking swept back headlamps, grille and bonnet. Differences set in at the rear giving its design an MPV like appearance. Mobilio on the other hand does the same thing as it receives a Brio like appearance. Honda has tried to give it a different look, with chrome grille and sporty looking bumper, but overall, the car still resembles Brio and Amaze. What stands out for Mobilio, is its rear design. Unlike Ertiga, the Honda MPV carries a very sporty rear, thanks to the clever design architecture from their designer.
Interiors: Moving onto the interiors, both Maruti Suzuki Ertiga and Honda Mobilio have advantages and disadvantages in this area. Talking about dashboard feel and design, it is Ertiga’s which feels and looks more premium than that of Mobilio. Feel of steering wheel is much better in Mobilio, but the instrument control of Ertiga gives a better appeal.
Space: Compared to Maruti Ertiga, Mobilio easily has more space. Doors that open wide for easy ingress and egress, more legroom, bigger rear window, tumble seats for second row giving easy passage into third row, etc gives Mobilio a clear win over Ertiga when it comes to interior space and accessibility for passengers during travel.
Speaking about third row seats, Ertiga hardly offers any legroom, and is only meant for kids. On the other hand, Mobilio offers plenty. We had three six footers sitting one behind the other, and the legroom was still not a problem. The above image was clicked with both cars second row seats pushed all the way back.
Boot and storage space in Mobilio are larger as compared to Ertiga. Mobilio also has more cubby holes and bins in cabin area for additional storage. Seat fabric of Ertiga is better, and so is the comfort and cushioning.
Infotainment: During the media drive, Honda said that Mobilio includes a touchsceen infotainment system with head unit playing video and an in built satellite navigation system. But as of now, they have revealed that this system will not be present once the car is launched. This is due to a software issue which could not be fixed. They have said that the 6.1 inch touchscreen AVN might return at a later stage. The woody panel on dash will also be given a miss. Ertiga receives a basic audio system compatible with USB and Aux-in, same is the case with Mobilio. Speaker quality of Ertiga is slightly better than that of Ertiga.
Engine and Mileage: Comparing diesel engine specifications, the upcoming Honda Mobilio will undercut competition where mileage is concerned. Mobilio will be seen powered by a 4 cylinder 1.5 liter DOHC i-DTEC engine with 100 PS peak power at 3,600 rpm and 200 Nm torque at 1750 rpm mated to a 5 speed manual gearbox. Martui Suzuki Ertiga ZDI diesel variant is powered by a 4 cylinder 1.3 liter DOHC DDiS engine offering 90 PS at 4000 rpm and 200 Nm torque at 1750 rpm mated to a 5 speed manual gearbox. The difference lies in fuel efficiency wherein the Ertiga engine offers 20 kmpl while the Mobilio claims to have fuel efficiency of 24.2 kmpl mileage which is not offered by any other MPV on sale in India.
For petrol engine option, Mobilio comes with Honda’s 1.5l iVTEC generating 119 PS and 145 Nm torque. Ertiga comes with 1.4l K Series engine delivering 95 PS power and 130 Nm torque. Mileage claimed by Maruti is 16 kmpl, while that by Honda is 17.3 kmpl.
Driving and Performance: Of the two, Mobilio is a driver’s car. Both petrol and diesel engine variants are not only more powerful as compared to Maruti Ertiga, but they are also more refined. Power delivery is better and steering is responsive. In case of Ertiga, the steering is heavier, engine is more noisy, and NVH levels are not as good as Honda Mobilio.
But thanks to better cushioning of seats, Maruti Ertiga scores more when out on a long journey. But again, there is a glitch. It is only good for 5 adults to travel in comfort, whereas Mobilio is good to go for 7 adults.
Conclusion: Honda Mobilio and Maruti Ertiga each have their advantages and disadvantages. But in the end, when we count overall, it is the Mobilio which comes out on the top. Though, it is still early to award the prize to Mobilio, as the most important aspect is yet to be revealed, its price.
Below is a tabular format of Honda Mobilio vs Maruti Ertiga (Price of Mobilio updated)
|Maruti Ertiga||Maruti Ertiga||Maruti Ertiga||Honda Mobilio||Honda Mobilio|
|Turning radius (m)||5.2||5.2||5.2||5.4||5.4|
|Type||K-Series Petrol Engine with VVT||K-Series Petrol Engine with VVT||DDiS Diesel Engine||i-VTEC||i-DTEC DOHC|
|Number of cylinders||4||4||4||4||4|
|Number of valves||16||16||16||16 SOHC||16|
|Fuel distribution||Multipoint Injection||MPI||CRDI (Common Rail Direct Injection)||MPFi||MPFi|
|Bore (mm) x Stroke (mm)||73 x 82||73×82||69.6 x 82||N/A||N/A|
|Maximum power (PS@rpm)||95 @ 6000||82 @ 6000||90 @ 4000||119 @ 6,600||100 @ 3,600|
|Maximum torque (Nm@rpm)||130 @ 4000||110 @ 4000||200 @ 1750||145 @ 4,600||200 @ 1,750|
|Emission||BSIV OBD-2||BS-IV OBD-2||BSIV OBD-2||N/A||N/A|
|Milegae||16.02 kmpl||17.65 km/kg||20.77||17.3 kmpl||24.2|
|Kerb weight (Kg)||1,160||1,235||1,846 (Gross)||1,131-1,160||1214-1245|
|Power steering type||EPS & Tilt||EPS & Tilt||EPS & Tilt||Collapsible Electric Power Steering||Collapsible Electric Power Assisted|
|Front||McPherson Strut||McPherson Strut||McPherson Strut||McPherson Strut||McPherson Strut|
|Rear||Torsion Beam||Torsion Beam||Torsion Beam||Torsion Beam||Torsion Beam|
|Front / Rear||185/65 R15||185/65 R15||185/65 R15||185/65 R15||185/65 R15|
|Boot Volume (L)||135||N/A||135||200||200|
|Fuel tank capacity (L)||45||60||45||42||42|
|Price (ex-showroom Delhi)||Rs. 5.80 – Rs. 7.35 lakhs||Rs. 6.40 – Rs. 7.15 lakhs||Rs. 7.22 – Rs. 8.49 lakhs||Rs. 6.49 – Rs. 8.78 lakhs||Rs. 7.89 – Rs. 9.60 lakhs|
Further Read – Honda Mobilio Review: Stylish 7 Seater Petrol and Deisel MPV
Email - [email protected]